Mike and Kelly hadn’t sold a home in 22 years. In 2026, they sold two: their custom ranch in Middleville and a family home in the Crystal Springs neighborhood of Caledonia. Different homes, different buyers, different markets. They chose Yoder Real Estate both times.
At a glance
Two homes. Two different markets. Same team.
Middleville
- The home
- Custom ranch on wooded acreage along Duncan Creek
- Situation
- Downsizing and building their next home
- Preparation
- Months of preparation and a pre-listing inspection; listed as a Certified Pre-Owned home
- Listed
- Late April 2026
- Buyer’s agents said
- “Appreciate all the pro-active repairs”
Crystal Springs, Caledonia
- The home
- Fairway home on StoneWater Country Club’s 18-hole course
- Situation
- A family home, no time crunch
- Preparation
- Pre-listing inspection, then a kitchen and main-level update; listed as a Certified Pre-Owned home
- Listed
- September 2026
- Buyer’s agents said
- “Showed like a model”
Their situation
Mike and Kelly were downsizing and building a new home, and they were counting on the sale of their Middleville home to help fund it. They had a lot going on at once, and it had been a long time since they had sold a house.
“We hadn’t sold a house in 22 years, so we were kind of behind the times in terms of how does this process work. We needed to get re-educated.”
— Mike
“I remember telling you that for me, this was a very emotional sale. It’s the sale of our family home where we raised our kids.”
— Kelly
They interviewed several agents before deciding, and Yoder Real Estate was their top pick.
Middleville: Selling a Longtime Family Home While Downsizing

What they needed
The home sits on wooded acreage in a rural part of Middleville, on well and septic. In Mike’s words, there were “not a lot of houses at that price point,” so they worried about demand. Timing mattered too, because their next home depended on the sale.
“We were using the proceeds from the house to build our next house. And so, what if it sits on the market for six months?”
— Mike
A plan that started months before listing
The work started at their dining room table the November before they listed. Kevin asked what this sale needed to accomplish for them, not just what the house was worth. Kelly remembers that he understood it wasn’t just about numbers: there were a lot of memories in that house.
“When you left, Mike and I both said, ‘Kevin’s the one. His team is the one.”
Over the following months, they worked through a punch list of improvements. None of the other agents they had talked to suggested a pre-listing inspection, and the idea made sense to them right away. For Kelly, it mattered that they did things the right way and handed the home to the next family in great condition.
“If I’m a prospective buyer and I see they had the house pre-inspected: they’re not trying to hide anything. They’re putting all their cards on the table.”
— Mike

Pricing for the market they were actually in
Their biggest worry was demand: a rural home at a price point with few comparable homes nearby, and a new build that depended on the sale.
“We really landed at a good price, at a fair price, a price that made a lot of sense, that would generate enough interest and demand and offers. And that’s exactly what happened.”
— Mike
Communication from start to finish
Mike and Kelly asked early on to be kept in the know, because the process was so unfamiliar. Everyone they spoke with on the team kept them updated on where things stood and what came next, which took a lot of anxiety away.
“The Yoder team did an amazing job communicating, staying in touch, kind of having a step-by-step. ‘Here’s where we are. We’re right where we want to be, on track.”
— Kelly
The result
The home was listed in late April 2026. Six buyer’s agents showed it in the first three days, it received two offers, and it was under contract in 3 days. One buyer’s agent wrote that their clients “appreciate all the pro-active repairs.”
“When it came around to getting an offer and waiting for the buyer’s inspection, we were in a position of strength. We knew there wouldn’t be any surprises.”
— Mike
Why They Hired Yoder Real Estate Again
Mike and Kelly also had a second family home to sell, in the Crystal Springs neighborhood of Caledonia. After Middleville, choosing an agent for it was an easy decision.
“Having already had such a fantastic experience with the Yoder team, we felt completely at ease. We just placed this into your hands.”
They already knew how Kevin would market the home, and that he would bring the best pricing options and ideas for updates that would pay off. As Mike saw it, why not get the very best: the experience of Kevin and the team.
Crystal Springs: A Different Home in a Different Market

What was different
This sale had no time pressure, and the home sat in a denser neighborhood with plenty of comparable homes. Mike expected it to be an easy sale.
Inspect first, then update
The home had a pre-listing inspection in the spring, months before it went on the market, so the family knew its condition before spending anything. It showed the big systems were recent. Kevin then walked the home and recommended where updates would pay off.



“When you walked through the kitchen, you had ideas on how to transform that… Looking back, those made a massive difference in the final price of the house.”
— Mike
Reading the market in real time
The home was listed in September 2026 at $549,900 as a Certified Pre-Owned home with a one-year home warranty. Buyer’s agents rated the price in line with market value, and most said it “showed like a model.” One wrote, “Sellers did an excellent job of getting the home ready for market.”
“Within the first day, you called me and said, ‘Hey, I think we should set a Tuesday noon deadline.”
— Mike
Mike credits that first-day call with making a real difference.
The result
Four offers came in by the deadline. The home was under contract in 5 days and sold for $551,900, $2,000 over list price, with no seller concessions.
“Kevin, you had kind of an upside pricing vision that we didn’t have.”
— Mike
“It turned out to sell for way more than we ever thought it could.”
— Kelly
What Mattered Most to Them
Asked what they would tell another homeowner choosing an agent, Mike and Kelly kept coming back to the same few things.
A plan built for the current market
“How the market was three months ago or six months ago, that may be old, that may be out of date. We didn’t want to be using an old plan.”
“The process was adaptive. It’s a flowing process… and it’s adaptive in real time. That was very, very important to us.”
A strategy for their home, not a template
“We weren’t just a number. We were important, and understanding our needs, that really sold it to us.”
“Here’s how we do your specific house. Here’s the do’s and the don’ts, the whats and the whys. Here’s how we’re going to market this house.”
Integrity and genuine care
“To be confident in your integrity, your character as a person, was important to us. Your honesty was important to us.”
“The full breadth of the team, it’s just… a well-oiled machine.”
Two sales, same experience
“On both occasions, on two different homes, two different types of homes, two different market dynamics, all that rang very true for us.”
“We had two successful sales that were not stressful, and we just couldn’t be happier with you and your team.”
“I would say that Yoder Real Estate went above and beyond for us twice.”
“In their words: interview excerptsClick to read what Mike and Kelly told Kevin+
Kevin: So once we got started, what stood out to you about the way Yoder Real Estate prepared, marketed and managed the sale?
Mike: That house in Middleville, it’s in a more rural area, not a lot of houses at that price point. And so we were worried about demand. We were worried about how many showings are we going to get… There was a pricing strategy months in advance, but when we really got to it: what are the real-time market dynamics, and what are other comparable homes? I thought we really landed at a good price, at a fair price, a price that made a lot of sense. And that’s exactly what happened.
Kevin: What would you tell somebody who’s sitting down and interviewing agents? How would you help them decide?
Mike: It was such a detailed plan and process from when we first chose to go with the Yoder team: all the consistent communications, pricing strategy, marketing strategy, analytics, really understanding the marketplace. But again, the personalized experience, the genuine care and concern. We weren’t just a number.
Kelly: And I think we also knew, and felt strongly, that you and your team were going to do your very best for us. We didn’t always know what that looked like, but we felt so confident that you knew. And we had two successful sales that were not stressful.
Is This You?
Mike and Kelly’s story may sound familiar if you are:
- Downsizing after many years in the same home
- Selling while building or buying your next home
- Selling a home full of family memories
- Selling a parent’s or family member’s home
- Not sure which repairs or updates are worth it before listing
- Worried about how today’s market will respond to your home
Considering selling in West Michigan?
Start with a strategy built around what you need the sale to accomplish.
Request a Seller Strategy SessionYoder Real Estate, brokered by LPT Realty. Individual results vary. Mike and Kelly’s comments reflect their own experience.